I have done this meme a few times over the last couple of years - but in the past I have either been given Spike, or James as one of the guys ... then it's easy to decide one of the catagories.
However
She gave me -
Cary Grant
Sean Bean
Kevin Sorbo

Cary Grant - an amazing actor, who was very talented - very pretty when young, yet aged beautifully.
He could say a lot with a look, or just a smile ... so, he has to be MARRY

Sean Bean - I really loved his character of Sharpe, and has a great grin. He is a good actor, but not (IMHO) as adaptable ... so would be fun on the short term - so has to be SHAG

Kevin Sorbo - yes, I do like him as Hercules, and most of the time in Andromeda ... but he can be a bit hard going. In some of the photos when I was looking for these, he really lets his hair go long and straggly ... not a good look ... so, all in all, over the CLIFF he goes
Yes, it was hard when I first saw the list ... sad no James to think about! But once I started thinking on the 3, the results were fairly simple.